Best Pizza restaurant in Cuyahoga Falls.
From Italy with love.
A rich tradition of authentic Italian woodfired pizza is now available in Cuyahoga Falls.
From Italy with love.
At Mattioli's Pizza, we take pride in serving artisan wood-fired pizza from our family recipe and fresh ingredients from Italy.
Be sure to try our exclusive Pizza Cupcakes and enjoy our full bar on our patio!
At Mattiloi's Pizza, you can easily order your favorite comfort food online, including wood-fired pizza and fresh salads. Enjoy convenient delivery or opt for takeout in downtown Cuyahoga Falls.
Start Your OrderCheck out our most recent reviews!
OMG! (Dios mío!!) guys and girls this is the new pizza spot! It's legit: I worked in Bronx , Brooklyn, queens, Chicago and live and work in Ohio , I can tell you this is awesome: just keep in mind when events /sporting/college stuff happening it's going to get busy. Could take a while. That is what has a few negative ... reviews. That's the way awesome pizza joints are. Pepperoni Pizza I added black olives mushroom, Cheese Pizza I added sausage mushroom, I ordered door dash and they had the pizza ready 6 -8 minutes that's Italian Neapolitan style. Driver grabbed it and in my hands 10 minutes. Amazing!!! Great talented team of people ! Can't wait to try other menu items . Thanks !! Read More
I went into going here with a bit of bias and an family discount due to my cousin however the pizza was amazingly tasty, the service was great I was able to make a custom pizza and basically made a delicious chicken pesto pizza with the chef even coming out and asking me if he got it right. ONE THING I will say is it ... is pricey and I did get a discount as I said but price is worth it for the food. Overall whenever I visit I will be coming back here and dining in maybe take out as well! Read More
Been wanting to try and I ordered a pepperoni for delivery. Was blown away with how good it was! Nice thin crust that's fully cooked and the cheese is perfectly melted. Will definitely order again!!
This place was awesome! I took my son there last night. The wood fired brick oven pizza was amazing and I feel like it’s something this area was missing. The meatballs were just like my Italian grandmother used to make “seriously they were the identical”. The coolest part is it’s a speakeasy so you enter through a ... hidden door in a pop machine. The atmosphere was a really cool speakeasy vibe they had Leather seats, brass tables, every kind of alcohol and drink you can think of and really kind and attentive staff. You could dress up really nice for that high end date night feeling or you could just pop in casually dressed for some drinks or pizza. This place is a really cool addition to Cuyahoga Falls and I hope it becomes a staple. Also the prices were really decent. Read More
We got the Neapolitan pizza and really enjoyed it! It had plenty of cheese, not too much sauce, and the crust has a good flavor. We’ll definitely be back to try other dishes and pizzas
Finally we have good authentic Italian wood fired pizza in this part of town. Excellent pizza, Prosciutto & Arugula, Poker club and a cheese. Next stop we try the Fig & Pear, salads and pasta! Thanks for the wonderfully crafted pizza.
Visit Mattiloi's Pizza in downtown Cuyahoga Falls today!